After Action Report: Rescue Resurrection Memphis, TN
The march to sit in front of defenders for their camera crews, after failed attempts at blockading both doors.
Rescue Resurrection, December 3-5, Memphis, TN
EVENT LOCATIONS:
Rescue Resurrection Academy, 708 N. Highland St., Memphis, TN
Planned Parenthood, 2430 Poplar Ave, Ste 100, Memphis, TN
THREAT SYNOPSIS:
Attempted blockades at clinic, resulting in the arrest of 17 people, threat of vehicle strike, excessive media presence, with potential for continued harassment, both to the clinic, and volunteers.
HIGH LEVEL TAKEAWAYS:
Collaboration between the clinic, law enforcement, and local and traveling volunteers was very successful
Effective mobilization and training of volunteers in a two week period to defend clinic doors, while working with clinic escorts to prevent the first attempt at blockades at both doors, resulting in a camera-focused sit in that did not prevent the passage of any patients.
The motivations of the speeches given at the hostile training facility, the cross section of attendees at the event, and the plans for future actions in multiple states, points toward a continued pattern of escalation in coming months.
Offsite speeches and conversations encouraged violent escalation and pointed participants toward resources and potential collaborators. The majority of participants onsite were either seasoned blockaders who have multiple arrests under their belt, violent offenders, thought leaders who preach the importance of escalation and being “battle ready,” veterans of the original Operation Rescue, and some were even featured on the Army of God website.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Rescue Resurrection (RR) is a new campaign formed by Randall Terry of Operation Rescue (OR), and Terrisa Bukovinac of Progressive Anti-Abortion Uprising (PAAU), under the new legal entity Viva Cristo Rey, Inc. Viva Cristo Rey took possession of the school, church, and residences formerly owned by Bellevue Baptist Church at 704 North Highland Street, Memphis TN. The organization has been explicit in their intention to use the facilities to train new anti-abortion activists to “bring back rescue” in the tradition of Terry’s reign at Operation Rescue, which resulted in hundreds of arrests, arsons, and shootings at abortion clinics throughout the 80s and 90s. While reproductive health clinics in Tennessee no longer provide abortions due to a state ban, RR went forward with their intentions to blockade the clinic, while pushing the narrative in their social media posts and to law enforcement that the clinic’s practice of referring patients out of state to access services constitutes some violation related to moving minors cross-state.
Most notably, while the group in attendance was small, the people that did show up were from a wide range of ideologies (Operation Rescue, Progressive Anti-Abortion Uprising, Red Rose Rescue, Army of God), but shared the common goal of escalation. While speakers talked about starting a metaphorical fire on camera, in the church, attendees were being directed to resources if they wanted to step up their activism into violence.
EVENT CONTEXT
Planned Parenthood Memphis Health Center Midtown is one of two Planned Parenthood locations in the Memphis region (though the other is temporarily closed), and is not a member of the National Abortion Federation, but does have its own security team and the support of Planned Parenthood national. The clinic does not currently provide abortion services, but does refer patients out of state.
The clinic allowed volunteer clinic escorts to support patients inside the parking lot, and on the public land where anti-abortion protesters gathered. In the last several years, they had discontinued their clinic escort program, as it was no longer necessary with the end of abortion services, however the core group of escorts reconvened for this event, with new additions from other local allied groups. Escorts and defenders practiced a strict non-engagement model with protesters, and for the purposes of the event, had a ring of clinic defenders circling each door to prevent blockaders, preventing protesters from barring it completely, allowing for no disruption of clinic activity.
The protesters leading this event have employed a number of tactics at other clinics in the past, including blockading doors, gluing locks, chaining themselves to gates and other infrastructure, accessing the clinic lobby via false appointments or force, graphic signage, harassment of and violence against clinic escorts, including harassment of them online, and in public spaces off clinic property, targeting them and their families, family businesses, and legal harassment. They also have close associations with people who have carried out extreme violence against abortion providers, including arson and murder. Participants in attendance included convicted arsonists, and people who are featured on the Army of God website, or in active communication with former Army of God leader, Michael Bray. Their current call to action is a direct reference to the history of violence against abortion providers that led to the passing of the FACE Act.
HISTORIC THREATS AND POTENTIAL ACTORS
NATIONAL ASSESSMENT/CONTEXT
Current status of the FACE Act
Normally, abortion facilities are federally protected by the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act, which is enforced by the FBI Reproductive Rights Task Force. In January 2025, President Trump pardoned 23 individuals who had been convicted of FACE Act Violations, and signed an DOJ memo to demand that the FBI no longer pursue FACE violations, except in extraordinary circumstances. Due to the recent policy changes, it is safe to assume that there will be no assistance from the FBI on FACE violations.
REGIONAL ASSESSMENT/CONTEXT
Human Life Protection Act
In August of 2022, Tennessee enacted the Human Life Protection Act, banning abortion procedures with limited medical emergency exceptions throughout the state. Any remaining health facilities do not provide abortion services, but may refer patients out of state to obtain services.
HB 1314 – State anti-doxing legislation
HB 1314 combats the threat of mass violence online, otherwise known as “doxing.” The law makes it a Class E felony to threaten an “act of mass violence” by any means of communication. The felony is enhanced to a Class D felony if the threat involves a school property, house of worship, government office, or at a live performance or event. There is also an additional Class B misdemeanor added by the law for the offense of posting a person’s telephone number and address online with the intent to threaten or cause harm. If harm is caused by the threat, the misdemeanor is enhanced to Class A.
HB 0099 and SB 0685 – State legislation against unlawful photography
The law enhances the penalty from a Class A misdemeanor to a Class E felony for an unlawful photograph that would offend or embarrass an ordinary person if the photograph was focused on an intimate area of the body. This also requires the offended, if convicted, to be registered as a sexual offender. The law also enhances a Class E felony to a Class D felony when the defendant unlawfully shares photos involving minors under 13 years old. If the defendant was in a position of trust or authority over the minor, that Class D felony is increased to a Class C felony.
THREAT ACTORS
Operation Rescue
Operation Rescue (OR) is an abortion “abolitionist” organization that also has extreme anti-Muslim, anti-LGBTQ+ views. The leadership and followers of OR over the years also have a laundry list of criminal offenses - blockades, trespassing, arson, assault, and several members were part of the violent anti-abortion terrorist group Army of God, who held an annual event to celebrate people who had been incarcerated for killing abortion providers. Operation Rescue split into two organizations following founder Randall Terry’s departure – Operation Rescue (currently run by Troy Newman), and Operation Save America (currently run by Jason Storms). In recent years, there has been a drastic increase in members participating in blockades of abortion clinics, with several of them resulting in arrests and FACE charges. All of those cases were pardoned by Donald Trump in January of 2025. Under Terry’s leadership from 1987 to 1989, OR was responsible for thousands being arrested during weeks long clinic blockades. During one of these marathon blockades in 1988 – the Seige of Atlanta - several of the incarcerated members of Operation Rescue collaborated on the Army of God manual, a handbook of violent practices for disrupting abortion clinics, including an entire chapter on the construction of explosives.
Progressive Anti-Abortion Uprising
Progressive Anti-Abortion Uprising (PAAU) is an abortion “abolitionist” organization that purports to be made up of progressive youth that include Democrats, members of the LGBTQ+ community, and activists that do not fit the typical conservative anti-abortion priorities. They are most well known for their participation in the theft of a box of medical waste containing the remains of 115 products of conception, which they then gruesomely displayed in videos on social media, and subsequently fetishized in craft projects, merchandise, and costumes for a protest outside of the White House. They are also known for “Pink Rose Rescue” clinic invasions (borrowed from the more explicitly Catholic Red Rose Rescues), where their members access clinic lobbies (often with fake appointments) to harass patients, giving them roses to convince them to cancel their appointments.
Red Rose Rescue
Red Rose Rescue (RRR) is a Catholic anti-abortion organization led by Fr. Stephen Imbaratto and Monica Migliorino Miller. RRR has a history of dozens of clinic invasions and blockades throughout the United States. In spite of the federal pardon for people convicted under the FACE Act, several members of Red Rose Rescue currently have active state level suits and terms of release restricting them from participating in clinic harassment activities.
Army of God
The Army of God (AOG) is an informal organization of anti-abortion extremists who were declared a Domestic Terror organization due to their association with clinic arsons, the murder of several abortion providers, and the creation of the Army of God manual, which provided detailed instructions for how to carry out violent actions against abortion clinics, and how to make bombs for that purpose.
Rescue Resurrection participants at Clinic
Randall Alan Terry
Front door blockade
Arrested
Memphis, TN
Founder of Operation Rescue
49 previous arrests for clinic blockades throughout the 80s and 90s
The Army of God handbook was created by imprisoned members of OR during their blockade campaigns of the 80s.
That same run of blockade campaigns led to the establishment of the FACE Act.
Runs for president pretty much every cycle as the Constitution Party candidate
Monica Miller
Front door blockade
Arrested
Citizens for a Pro-Life Society
Red Rose Rescue
South Lyon, MI
Multiple arrests related to previous invasions and blockades
Long history of fetus theft
NY Lawsuit against Red Rose Rescue encompassing several incidents
04/24/2021 – Manhasset, NY
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY
07/07/2022 – Hempstead, NY
Terrisa Bukovinac
Front door blockade
Arrested
PAAU, Pro-Life SF, Dems for Life
Washington, DC, may have relocated permanently to Memphis
Ran as a Democratic candidate for President in 2024, running graphic ads
Randall Terry was her campaign manager (and rival on the Constitution ticket)
Participated in theft of 115 fetuses from Washington Surgi-Center
Multiple other invasion arrests
Elise Ketch
Front door blockade – used a large board to block escorts with Richard Dur
Attempted blockade at back door with Randall Terry’s car, accelerating towards a clinic escort.
Arrested
PAAU
Multiple other invasion/blockade participation
Melanie Salazar
Front door blockade
Arrested
PAAU/Pro-Life San Francisco
San Francisco, CA
Multiple other invasions
09/29/2022 – San Diego, CA
Previous arrest for “justice for the 5” action in DC
Joan Andrews Bell
Front door blockade
Arrested
Previous associates include Army of God groomer John Burt, and murderer James Kopp
Hundreds of previous arrests for blockades
Literally too many to list, but one of the most noteworthy involved rushing in to a Jacksonville clinic with a KKK member (Burt) and pulling the tubes out of active aspiration machines.
Constance Becker
Back and front door blockades
Not arrested
PAAU
Previous arrest for “justice for the 5” action in DC
Alan Aversa
Front door blockade
Arrested
Arizona
John Hinshaw
Front door blockade
Arrested
Multiple arrests related to previous invasions and blockades
NY Lawsuit against Red Rose Rescue encompassing several incidents
04/24/2021 – Manhasset, NY
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY
07/07/2022 – Hempstead, NY
Nathan Berning
Front door blockade
Arrested
Let them Live
Org found guilty of fraud – failed to deliver $30k of support
Cathy Ramey
Front door blockade
Arrested
Featured on the Army of God website
Wrote In Defense of Others: A Biblical Analysis and Apologetic on the Use of Force to Save Lives
Participated in original Nuremberg Files website and posters
Emily Mahon
Front door blockade
Arrested
Dawn of Revival
Brighton, MI
James Carney
Front door blockade
Arrested
Utica, NY
Rome, NY
Rob Rudnick
Front door blockade
Arrested
Bend, OR
Operation Rescue veteran
Multiple previous arrests for blockades
2015 – Williston, ND
Richard P Dur
Front door blockade - used a large board to block escorts with Elise Ketch
Arrested
Prolife Alberta
Blue Direct
Alberta, CA
Alum of Leadership Institute
Work through Blue Direct/Prolife Alberta seems to be a shady influence campaign for elections
Matthew Connolly
Front door blockade
Arrested
St. Paul, MN
Multiple previous arrests for blockades and invasions
08/27/2021 – Philadelphia invasion barricaded in restroom
03/2023 – Southfield, MI – Red Rose Rescue
This case is being appealed to SCOTUS
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY Red Rose Rescue
With Goodman, Moscinski
NY Lawsuit against Red Rose Rescue encompassing several incidents
04/24/2021 – Manhasset, NY
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY
07/07/2022 – Hempstead, NY
Robert “Doc” Kovaly
Front Door blockade
Arrested
Hastings, MI
Arrested in West Bloomfield RRR invasion in 2017
With Miller, Connolly, Goodman, Woodworth
Alfred Lemmo
Front door blockade
Arrested
Dearborn, MI
Jennifer Patterson McCoy
Back door blockade
Not arrested
Wichita, KS
Operation Rescue Veteran
Clinic arsonist
Linda Yaklin Mueller
Back door blockade, not arrested
Milton, DE
Several previous invasions with RRR
Caleb Slater
Running for NY state senate
Syracuse, NY
Back and front door blockades
Not arrested
Paid homeless men to donate to his campaign to access matching funds
Associated with Life Matters Training Center
Gary Leber
Front door blockade
Not arrested
Ithaca, NY
Womens Life Services CPC
Operation Rescue veteran
Was in charge of managing the fetus they kept in formaldehyde for protests
Assaulted a federal marshal in 1992
1991 – federal charges for aggressive blockade in Wichita
Will Goodman
Onsite, did not participate in blockade
Active case - Delaware Co, PA Red Rose Rescue
Multiple other invasion and blockade arrests
NY Lawsuit against Red Rose Rescue encompassing several incidents
04/24/2021 – Manhasset, NY
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY
07/07/2022 – Hempstead, NY
Patty Woodworth
Onsite, but did not participate in blockade
Winona, MN
Red Rose Rescue
Multiple previous arrests related to invasions and blockades
Active case - Delaware Co, PA Red Rose Rescue
03/19/2019 – Washington, DC Capital Women’s Centers
With Goodman, Connolly
With Miller, Imbarrato, Moscinski, Bell, Connolly, Goodman
Missy Reilly Smith
Onsite for blockade, did not participate
Washington, DC
W.A.K.E. U.P.
Stole fetus “Philomena Grace”
At press conference following the DC blockade arrests and fetus recovery, she gave a speech about how Baltimore was being powered by burning fetuses.
2010 – was Tea Party candidate for DC delegate, running graphic ads
Randall Terry was her campaign manager
Robert Byrd
Front Door blockade, not arrested
Pro-Life San Francisco
Multiple other invasion participation
09/29/2022 – San Diego, CA
Susan (Susie) Lovato
Onsite, did not participate in blockade
Project manager for Rescue Resurrection
Memphis, TN
Memphis Coalition for Life
Michael McMonagle
Onsite, did not participate in blockade
Pro-Life Coalition of PA
OR veteran, multiple previous arrests for blockades
Named in 1989 Roe v. Operation Rescue with Terry and Foreman
https://crisismagazine.com/vault/uncivil-liberties-no-justice-for-operation-rescue.
Deported from China: https://catholicphilly.com/2008/08/news/local-pro-life-advocate-deported/
Christopher “Fidelis” Moscinski
Onsite, did not participate in blockade
Bronx, NY
Red Rose Rescue
Active pending case in NJ for other invasion
Multiple arrests related to previous invasions and blockades
NY Lawsuit against Red Rose Rescue encompassing several incidents
04/24/2021 – Manhasset, NY
11/27/2021 – White Plains, NY
07/07/2022 – Hempstead, NY
Tracy Ann Owens
Did not participate in blockade
Norwich, NY
Uplift
Joanna Myers
Front blockade
Not Arrested
New York, NY
Julie Rosati (Beyel)
Onsite for blockade, did not participate
Oneida, NY
Save the Storks, CareNet
Colin Lester Hudson
Onsite for blockade, did not participate
Milwaukee, WI
Operation Rescue, Pro Life Action League veteran, multiple previous arrests
Constitution Party elector
Emily Berning
Onsite for blockade, did not participate
Fort Wayne, IN
Richard Mahoney
Onsite for blockade, did not participate
St Joseph, MO
Claims to have been given fetal remains from a Baton Rouge clinic by a “dumpster diving homeless man”
Rescue Resurrection participants that did not go to the Clinic
Alveda King
MLK Jr’s neice
Priests for Life
Sr. Dede Byrne
Washington, DC
Believes Pro-Lifers need to be “battle ready”
Fr. Stephen Broden
Dallas, TX
Terry’s Constitution Party running mate
Rev. Msgr. Victor Ciaramitaro
Chris Marsh
Not at blockade
Cincinnatti, OH
Board member of Viva Christo Rey – the org that owns the property
Noteworthy excerpts from Church livestream on 12/3
00:00-05:00 – Terry discusses his & Fidelis’s conversations with Memphis police about their intentions and what to expect
03:37: Terry explains that Fidelis can't get arrested because he has a warrant out in NJ and if he gets arrested again he'd get "hung up in the system"
05:00-10:00 – Terry discusses the need for a (metaphorical) fire and how they need to be the ones to start it.
4:28:35, Fidelis says they don't know if anyone from the pro-abortion side will be there or not.
4:36:40: "Who wants to get locked? We have bike locks. And we have zip ties." — Bukovinac
4:43:50: "If there's pro-aborts there, we'll just sit around the pro-aborts. The point is to keep the facility closed."
RAW LINKS
Coverage of the event
PAAU turning on one of their own members
Previous blockade and invasion coverage